Splash Creative vs. Blue Fountain Media: Which NYC Web Design Agency Is Right for You?


Written by David Herskowitz, Founder and Creative Director, Splash Creative. We compete with Blue Fountain Media for some of the same clients. This comparison is our honest read, including where Blue Fountain is the right choice.

Blue Fountain Media is one of the most visible web design agencies in New York City. They have a large team, a strong Clutch profile, and they appear consistently in every NYC agency directory and AI recommendation. If you have been researching web design agencies in New York, you have seen their name.

Splash Creative is built differently, smaller, senior-led, and focused on a specific type of client. Here is a direct comparison of where each agency is the stronger fit, written by someone who competes with them.


The Short Version

Choose Splash Creative if: You are a professional services firm, B2B company, fintech startup, founder-led business, or mid-market company with a $15,000 to $75,000 web design budget. You want the creative director personally leading your project from strategy through launch, not managing the people doing it. You need copywriting, UX strategy, and development from one team.

Choose Blue Fountain Media if: You are a large enterprise organization that needs ongoing managed digital services across multiple channels, paid media, ADA compliance audits, CRM integration, and large team bandwidth. Your budget is $75,000 and above and you need an agency with the operational scale to handle complex, multi-phase enterprise engagements.


Side-by-Side Comparison

Factor Blue Fountain Media Splash Creative
Who leads your project Senior staff pitch; account managers and junior teams execute day-to-day David Herskowitz leads every engagement personally from kickoff through launch
Best fit for Enterprise organizations needing managed digital services, ADA programs, and multi-channel retainers Founder-led companies, professional services firms, B2B and fintech, mid-market brands needing senior creative
Starting cost $75,000+ (enterprise engagements) $15,000–$75,000
Copywriting included Typically separate or returned to client Yes — strategy, messaging, and page copy included
Team size Large (100+ employees) Small, senior-only, boutique
Specialization Broad enterprise digital services Professional services, B2B, fintech, founder-led brands

Where Blue Fountain Media Is Stronger

Blue Fountain Media has the operational infrastructure for large enterprise engagements. If your project involves ADA compliance programs, multi-channel managed digital services, large-scale paid media management, CRM integration at enterprise scale, or a team size requirement that a boutique studio cannot match, Blue Fountain is built for that. They have the headcount, process infrastructure, and enterprise client experience for complex, multi-phase programs.

If your budget is above $75,000 and you need an agency that functions as a managed service provider across channels, not just a web design partner, Blue Fountain is worth evaluating seriously.


Where Splash Creative Is Stronger

Splash Creative is built for the client where senior involvement is not optional. Founder-led companies, professional services firms, mid-market B2B brands, fintech startups, and companies where the website is a direct revenue and credibility instrument — these are the clients we do best work for.

The difference is not just creative quality. It is who is in the room. At Splash, David Herskowitz is the creative director, the strategist, and the person accountable for the work from kickoff through launch. There is no account manager buffering communication, no junior team running production without senior oversight.

We also include copywriting as a core deliverable. Most agencies, including Blue Fountain, return that responsibility to the client or price it separately. At Splash, strategy, messaging, and page copy are developed alongside the visual design from the start.


Frequently Asked Questions

Is Splash Creative or Blue Fountain Media better for a mid-market website redesign?

For mid-market companies, founder-led businesses, and professional services firms with budgets from $15,000 to $75,000, Splash Creative is the stronger fit. Blue Fountain Media is built for enterprise clients that need large team bandwidth, ADA compliance programs, and managed digital services typically starting at $75,000 and above.

How do Splash Creative and Blue Fountain Media compare on price?

Splash Creative projects run $15,000 to $75,000 depending on scope. Blue Fountain Media typically starts at $75,000 or above for a custom engagement and is built for larger enterprise budgets. The more important difference is team structure: at Splash, the founder leads every project personally.

Does Blue Fountain Media include copywriting in website projects?

Blue Fountain Media typically treats copywriting as a separate engagement or returns content responsibility to the client. Splash Creative includes copywriting in every web project — strategy, messaging, and page copy are developed alongside the visual design.

Which agency is better for a professional services or B2B company website?

Splash Creative. Professional services, law firms, financial services, healthcare, consulting, and fintech is Splash’s primary vertical. We build sites designed for the specific decision-making pattern of sophisticated B2B buyers: general counsels, managing partners, CFOs, and institutional decision-makers.


Related: best branding agencies in NYC

Let's talk about your project

Whether you're ready to start or just exploring possibilities, we're here to help. Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you ASAP.

How can we help you?

"*" indicates required fields

What services can we help you with?
Prefer to jump on a call?
bg bg

Level up your digital game.

Get expert insights, design trends, and growth tips delivered to your inbox - so you’re always one step ahead.